05-12-2018 11:40

L’Intrus Redux



“Just to put it bluntly,” she says, “should I be reading this exhibition as a diagnosis of what is happening in the world right now? And am I to understand that such a diagnosis primarily concerns what is happening to Europe? Isn’t what is happening to Europe ultimately a consequence of that which Europe refuses to address, except symptomatically? Where is the ‘real’ crisis in this crisis? From where does the ‘real’ violence originate, and who is the ‘real’ stranger?” 

I pause. Though numerous artists in L’Intrus are not European, it is indeed an exhibition about the problem created by Europe and its impossible imperial offspring, the United States. L’Intrus stages a range of responses to the process of fantasizing strangeness as something external to the body, at an individual level or at a collective socio-political level. I do assume that this problem originated in Europe, in the Cartesian split between body and mind, and in the evolution of that split in the form of a wish for some universal form of humanism. I say “wish” because to insist on sameness by virtue of an abstraction—the idea of the human—can and does frequently entail a disavowal of structural violence and its effects on the body. The rebuttal that “all lives matter” to the Black Lives Matter movement in the United States is the evil step-child of this idea.

If there is such a thing as “real” violence, I locate its origin in the projection of strangeness proper to oneself onto another. The splitting off from, the rejection of whatever is unacceptable to the (social) body inaugurates violence. I borrow this view, in part, from Jean-Luc Nancy, who is explicit on this point in “L’Intrus,” the essay after which the exhibition is conceptually framed and titled:

My heart was becoming my own foreigner—a stranger precisely because it was inside. Yet this strangeness could only come from outside for having first emerged inside. A void suddenly opened in my chest or my soul—it’s the same thing—when it was said to me: “You must have a heart transplant.” (Jean-Luc Nancy and Susan Hanson, L'intrus. Cr: the New Centennial Review. 2.3 (2002): 4.)  

Nancy’s treatise on the heart transplant provides a counter-model for representations of “strangers” by Europe, and by its ideological avatars elsewhere. Images of people in boats, in refugee camps, in shelters, in line to receive aid: these solidify a political understanding of the pictured people’s “strangeness” and their “intrusion” onto the European territory. They establish such people’s existence outside the established social order first, as the primary foundation of their identity vis-à-vis the viewer.  

Prevailing images of migrants also displace the heart of the problem, projecting its cause onto the arrival of people, rather than locating it in a process internal to Europe, which incited Europeans to leave that territory for centuries in order to devour resources elsewhere. Nancy suggests that the intrusion of l’intrus begins with the gradual alienation of a heart from its “proper” physical body, and I am borrowing this metaphor to suggest that the “intrusion” of migrants, refugees, asylum seekers, immigrants, tourists, seasonal laborers, and so on, begins with an analogous alienation within the political body.

Read more

  • International Museum Day 2017

    International Museum Day 2017

    In ancient times, museums were temples dedicated to the muses, for reflection and for the cultivation of the different sciences. Much, much later, they took the form of a “cabinet of curiosities” from private and religious collections. With the...

    Read more
  • Manny Farber "What students say" (1987)

    The importance of termites

    The world film calendar is heavily marked this month by what will take place at Cannes (17-28 May). We could say that everything starts and ends at Cannes. Cannes is where those films that will mark the year are bought and sold; the place where new...

    Read more
  • watching the grass grow. Maider López

    Big-bang, fish sex and watching grass grow. Agency of Living Organisms

    Sunday, February 5th was the last day for visiting the Agency of Living Organisms, curated by Pauline Doutreluingne. The exhibition has explored the relationships that become established between the different living phenomena in our environment, the...

    Read more
  • estimulantes_exposición

    Exhibition preview 2017

      On 17th February, we will inaugurate the first of the four exhibitions we have planned for this year. After almost two years of public programmes around modern-day stimulants such as coffee, cocoa, sugar and tobacco, we will present Stimulants:...

    Read more
  • Tabakalera, vista desde la otra orilla del Urumea

    Time for growing

    In two days we will be saying goodbye to 2016, a year we had long been designing in our mind’s eye. A year intensely lived, without fully grasping what was going on around us, without time to react, but with the firm conviction that it was an...

    Read more